Which version is better?

23 Responses to “Original Celtic Woman VS. Neo Celtic Woman You raise me Up.mpg”

  • KupkaykeLove:

    please note though that the original line up did not include hayley. the original line up in 2005 was Chloë Agnew, Órla Fallon, Lisa Kelly, Méav Ní Mhaolchatha, and Máiréad Nesbitt. Hayley joined in 2006

  • KupkaykeLove:

    i love both versions but the original will always be my favorite

  • LisaKellySingerHolic:

    Original!!!

  • reverendjackdunn:

    It’s like choosing a favorite child… you can’t.
    I’m happy to cherish each moment, each individual, each talent…
    I agree — God has blessed us with a little piece of heaven to enjoy while here on earth…
    Thank you — again… I can’t say it enough…
    God Bless

  • LucarioDrew:

    I miss Hayley Westerna from the original one…

  • TechnoNeotorand:

    i like the old, i wanna ask why the you raise me up part is you reyyyyyys me up i mean, and the shoulders before was very very perfect, and the new is stressing. but i love cleic womans, and i aspire to sing with them someeday, the original and new and the future, especially LISA KELLY! I LOVE HER!

    thumbs up if u agree

  • Jerameel Estrera:

    @fuzzynuggetman27
    you’re right.. that’s what I’m talking about.. Celtic Woman- A New Journey version is the best… full of chills and relaxing… soothing… plus goosebumps…

  • Jerameel Estrera:

    Here’s The best quality of Celtic Woman-A New Journey for the song You Raise Me Up.. Check for the High Quality video.. you’ll love it

  • Jerameel Estrera:

    Here’s The best quality of Celtic Woman-A New Journey for the song You Raise Me Up.. Check for the High Quality video.. you’ll love it

  • sefrims1:

    That was really interesting..a good job..it was fun to see the different versions..all done well. thanks for posting…

  • Jerameel Estrera:

    The A New Journey version is more angelic and soothing. If u compare Chloe’s and Lisa’s Songs from the Heart “voice appeal” to the A New Journey version, its not so stunning as it were in their A New Journey performance…. but the Songs From the Heart “You Raise Me Up” is still very beautiful and the intense spirit of the song is still there…. thanks to the ladies..

  • Jerameel Estrera:

    this comparison is unfair because the song is sung in different keys… the song in the original is sung in higher key,, and it is fantastic compared to the new one… the comparison is annoying…. but the new version cannot overlap the version with Orla, Meav and Hayley….

  • Jerameel Estrera:

    this comparison is unfair because the song is sung in different keys… the song in the original is sung in higher key,, and it is fantastic compared to the new one… the comparison is annoying…. but the new version cannot overlap the version with Orla, Meav and Hayley….

  • sharkswimmer5:

    I feel that anything Celtic Woman does is AWESOME! The newest version may seem better because of the better sound quality and graphics!

  • drmayeda1:

    I think they were both taken from videos that were being sold on Itunes. the song was sung as a group number in both A new Journey, and Songs from the Heart. A very good job of editing the two pieces together but a little hard to sort out which is which

  • ILoveRedtail:

    the videos are all sung in different keys… that annoys me… but I’m in band, so I hate every thing when it changes keys right in the middle of a song…

  • happykitty1816:

    I absolutely love lisa.<3 I swear she gets more and more beautiful.

  • Tangerine258:

    Of course Slane Castle. It is 100000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 times better than that of SFTH. 

  • Theonehewsings53:

    Slane Castle all the way!!!!!!!!!

  • x6wmj8a4:

    I like the new version the best because it has the second verse to it and the previous ones didn’t have it. I still love all the versions of this song.

  • MrBrthomp:

    to me it seems that they held back during songs from the heart. they put so much more into their proformance during a new journey.

  • hansbmd20:

    There are pros and cons to both versions. What I like about SftH is that it has that second verse of Lynn’s, and I like Lynn and Alex’s voices. But ANJ has Meav and Hayley’s beautiful blend on the second chorus, Orla’s haunting voice and Lisa’s powerful voice on the first chorus. I thought that first chorus in SftH was just lacking without that power and strength. So my vote is for A New Journey.

  • soccergladiator5:

    I never noticed the 2 different keys……however, I think both versions are absolutely fantastic. It’s really hard to choose between such different talents.

Leave a Reply

Archived Posts